Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake – The No-Bake Family Favorite!

Indulge in the sublime taste of the Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake, a no-bake masterpiece that’s become a family favorite across generations. With its silky and rich consistency, each bite promises a delightful symphony of flavors that linger pleasantly on your palate. This cheesecake captures the essence of New York’s culinary flair, combining creamy textures with a buttery, crumbly crust that’s hard to resist.

This no-bake cheesecake is perfect for both novice and seasoned bakers looking to create a decadent dessert without the fuss of using an oven. Its ease of preparation makes it a convenient option for any occasion, whether it’s a holiday gathering or simply satisfying a craving. With the use of fresh and high-quality ingredients, this cheesecake not only stands out for its taste but also for its sophisticated aroma that fills the room with comfort and warmth. Relish in this timeless dessert that brings joy to every celebration and quiet evening alike.

Quick Recipe Highlights

• Flavor Profile: This cheesecake combines a rich and creamy filling with a perfect balance of sweetness, complemented by a hint of vanilla that enhances its overall depth of flavor.
• Texture: The cheesecake offers a smooth and velvety texture, contrasted beautifully by a slightly crunchy, buttery graham cracker crust.
• Aroma: The subtle aroma of vanilla and tangy cream cheese entices the senses, promising a deliciously fulfilling dessert experience.
• Visual Appeal: Presented with a glistening appearance, this cheesecake has a golden crust and a creamy white filling that’s flawlessly smooth and inviting.
• Skill Level Needed: Even beginners will find this recipe manageable, as it requires simple mixing techniques and no baking skills.
• Special Equipment: An electric mixer is essential for achieving the right consistency in the filling, and a springform pan is recommended for easy removal of the cheesecake.

Recipe Overview

• Difficulty Level: Easy — Minimal steps involved, making it suitable even for those who have never tackled a cheesecake before. Achieving its creamy consistency requires only basic mixing skills.
• Category: Dessert — Perfect to be enjoyed after dinner or as a sweet treat during the day, making it versatile for any dessert table.
• Cuisine: American, particularly New York-style cheesecake, known for its ultra-creamy texture and rich flavor.
• Cost: Moderate — Using quality cream cheese and fresh ingredients ensures the best flavor without breaking the bank.
• Season: All-year-round — Appropriate for any season, but particularly refreshing in spring and summer due to its no-bake preparation.
• Occasion: Ideal for birthdays, anniversaries, and holiday gatherings, this cheesecake adds a touch of elegance and indulgence to any celebration.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

The Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake seduces with its divine creaminess and sumptuous taste. A single slice envelops your taste buds in a symphony of soft, silky textures, providing a luxurious dessert experience. The delicate vanilla notes and the rich cream cheese blend into a sweet, lightly tangy treat that demands a second helping. This cheesecake stands out as a centerpiece for its delightful balance of flavors—neither too sweet nor too tangy—perfectly rounded with its aromatic vanilla essence.

If time and convenience are what you seek in a dessert recipe, this no-bake cheesecake is a definitive winner. Prepared without the meticulous tasks of baking, it requires only mixing and chilling, saving you time and effort while delivering a gourmet-level dessert. Its simplicity extends beyond the recipe; with no need for complex techniques, it’s equally accessible to beginners and veteran bakers alike.

Not only does this cheesecake excel in taste, but its ingredients offer nutritional benefits as well. Rich in calcium and proteins from the cream cheese, this dessert can be a source of dietary enjoyment without excessive guilt. The balanced portions provide essential nutrients while satisfying your sweet cravings, making it an occasional indulgence that aligns with mindful eating.

The cheesecake’s alluring reputation extends beyond its taste to its impressive role in social settings. Its elegant appearance and delectable flavor make it a sought-after star for gatherings, ensuring your culinary skills leave a lasting impression. Whether presented at a dinner party or shared at family reunions, its universal appeal is undeniable. Those who try it are often surprised by how much this no-bake version mirrors the baked classic’s decadence.

Affordability and accessibility of ingredients further enhance the appeal of this cheesecake. With simple, readily available items, this recipe accommodates even the most budget-conscious home cooks. The cost-effective choice of ingredients retains the spirit of a lavish dessert, without escalating expenses. Thus, the Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake represents an achievable luxury that delights your guests and delivers satisfaction with ease.

Historical Background and Cultural Significance

Originating from ancient Greece, where cheesecake was served to Olympians as energy-boosting nourishment, the concept has significantly evolved over centuries. The New York-style cheesecake emerged in the early 20th century, embodying the epitome of cheesecakes with its unique methods and creamy consistency. As a contemporary classic, this cheesecake remains revered worldwide, showcasing New York City’s vibrant culinary legacy.

The cultural importance of cheesecake shines during celebrations and holidays. Over generations, it has become an iconic dessert choice, symbolizing festivity and indulgence. Its versatility to adapt to different flavors and ingredients makes it a staple in recipe books globally. No gathering feels complete without the unmistakable allure of a cheesecake centerpiece inviting everyone to indulge.

Throughout history, cheesecake recipes have morphed and adapted to suit the tastes and dietary preferences of various eras and regions. The New York-style iteration stands out for its richness—a hallmark believed to have taken root from Jewish delicatessens in the city. This incarnation has set the gold standard, inspiring an array of versions from Italy’s ricotta-based counterparts to Japan’s lighter, souffle-like approach.

Modern regional variations diversify as ingredients and dietary inclinations evolve. While the traditional New York-style remains beloved for its dense, creamy texture, other adaptations feature refreshing elements like berries and citrus zests, catering to lighter palates. The cheesecake’s role as a versatile, fine dessert paves the way for innovative versions that celebrate both culinary heritage and creative improvisation.

Ingredient Deep Dive

Cream cheese, the heart of this cheesecake, was inspired by French Neufchâtel and became beloved by Americans in the form of block cream cheese. Its tang adds depth while contributing richness essential to the cheesecake’s soft, velvety texture. Packed with calcium and healthy fats, it balances indulgence with modest nutritional advantages, reinforcing the backbone of the cheesecake experience.

When selecting cream cheese, opt for full-fat versions to capture the signature taste and texture. Ensure it’s softened before mixing to prevent lumps, achieving the luscious consistency every cheesecake demands. Stored well in a refrigerator, it maintains freshness needed for this delicate dessert, but opened packages should be consumed within two weeks to preserve quality.

Graham crackers are the basis for the cheesecake’s crust, celebrated for their distinct texture and gentle sweetness. Beyond their crunch, they add important contrast to the cream filling’s smoothness. As a pantry staple, graham crackers maintain convenience, bridging the gap between simplicity and taste. Their natural ability to retain texture even after chilling reinforces the reputable crust expected from a quality cheesecake recipe.

Alive with adaptable potential, graham crackers can find alternatives, like digestive biscuits or biscoff cookies, presenting new flavors and modifications. Should you need a gluten-free option, replacing with gluten-free cookies accesses this sublime treat for everyone. Store them in an airtight container, ensuring constant freshness that enhances your kitchen endeavors.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Using cold cream cheese: Always ensure that your cream cheese is at room temperature for a smooth consistency.
• Over-mixing: This can introduce air into the filling, which affects the texture and can lead to cracks.
• Skipping the chilling time: Essential for setting the cheesecake; patience is key for perfect slices.
• Improper graham cracker crust forming: Make sure it’s compacted well to avoid a crumbly base.
• Using expired ingredients: Freshness is vital to the cheesecake’s flavor and texture; check expiry dates.
• Ignoring portion sizes: Make sure to measure accurately to maintain the balance of flavors.
• Wrong pan size: Using the incorrect size can result in an improperly set cheesecake.
• Not lining the pan: Use parchment for easy release from the springform pan.
• Skipping the crust chilling: A firm crust holds better when poured with filling overtop.

Essential Techniques

Mastering the smooth texture of the Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake starts with properly mixing the cream cheese. Soft, room temperature cream cheese ensures a luscious filling free from unsightly lumps. Folding the ingredients instead of vigorously whisking avoids incorporating unwanted air. A visual indication of mastery arises when the filling gleams and sports smooth, even surfaces—crack-free and unblemished.

Preparing the graham cracker crust demands attention to detail. A firm pressing technique ensures the base remains sturdy under the weight of the cheesecake filling. Using the base of a flat glass helps evenly distribute pressure, creating a cohesive crust bound for success. Small cracks during setting are traditionally signs of domestic artistry, yet consistent pressure and chilling assure perfection for proud display.

Chilling is pivotal, constituting the crucial endpoint that sends the filling into a cooled stasis, initiating the cheesecake’s quintessential taste and texture transformation. Be vigilant about timing, adhering to the minimum 4 hours, and ideally, allow your creation to rest overnight. Not only does the texture set fully, but flavors synergize during this resting phase, offering a mature finish bursting with harmonized taste.

The springform pan is indispensable for easily releasing the cheesecake after chilling, enabling flexible removal without disrupting the set textures. Practically elegant, the pan epitomizes simplicity and function—immortalizing flawless cheesecake domes ready to embrace whatever final decorative flourish imagination dictates. Properly greasing or lining the pan mitigates potential intricacies of disassembly.

Pro Tips for Perfect Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake

To achieve an Ultra-smooth filling, always use room temperature cream cheese, allowing the easy dissolution of ingredients. For flavor enhancement, a touch of lemon juice adds vibrancy, contrasting the cream’s richness. Incorporate zest cautiously for subtle undertones.

Crust fans seeking strong complements may prefer digestives or Oreos, establishing a delightful chocolaty foundation beneath the creamy pinnacle. Mix them for customized crust experiences. Use a springform pan, ensuring a seamless release for picture-perfect presentations. This tool is indispensable for cheesecake aficionados.

Setting manifold aims: chilling adequately is non-negotiable, garnering flavor fusion and perfected textures during these hours of refrigeration, crafting an evenly distributed filling that stands with elegance.

Presentation professionals might pour a fine sour cream topping or drizzle chocolate gently, creating visual allure through a refined artistic touch. Enjoyable, edible decoration elevates homemade aestheticism effortlessly. Garnish imaginatively—fresh berries or caramel provide poetic contrasts blooming atop your immaculate centerpiece.

Serve with confidence by swapping humble knives for smooth blades dipped in hot water when slicing—the result: pristine, inviting portions demanding admiration. Cleanliness is crucial; each line should beckon desirably to waiting hands, bringing artistry and culinary craftsmanship full circle.

Variations and Adaptations

Embrace regional deviations by exploring Chicago-style options with additional creaminess from sour cream mixtures. These adaptations bring forth slightly different textures and pleasantly tart undertones familiar to Midwestern desserts. Each variation respects the essential fabric of cheesecake while broadening horizons.

During summer months, introduce berries or other seasonal fruits to adorn the surface. A refreshing adaptation welcomes lightly macerated fruit toppings that inspire vibrancy—slices promising harmonic fusion of sweet and tangy with cream cheese’s rich neutrality.

Dietary modifications offer inclusion without sacrificing flavor. Swap in lactose-free cream cheese or opt for vegan counterparts available at major retailers. These changes ensure universal enjoyment without compromising the hallmark qualities tied to this beloved dessert.

For adventurous palates, consider adding a flavored extract such as almond or maple. These can transform subtlety into unique flavor journeys, enriching the cheesecake’s foundational beauty without overpowering its inherent elegance.

Dare to transform base textures by substituting bases—a chocolate cookie transforms structures, augments texture, and provokes curiosity in diners ready to explore changes masquerading within familiar packaging.

Presentation can play whimsical explorations—personalized mini jars offer portable pleasure, not only catering to convenience but establishing a nostalgic return to mason-jar memoiritis, capturing imagination on-the-go.

Serving and Presentation Guide

Plating an Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake invites observers to indulge before the first bite. Center each piece perfectly on the plate, reflecting chefs’ artistic disciplines. For refined garnishing, consider seasonal fruits or a dusting of powder—aesthetic embellishments illuminating culinary prowess.

For complementary textures, crushed nuts form decorative fringes, creating contrast both visually and texturally. Embedding subtle sophistication, consider pairing crushed pistachios for a rustic flair or toasted almonds aligning elegantly with cheesecake grandeur.

Traditional accompaniments like dollops of whipped cream socializing alongside each slice ensures harmony—spoon or pipe it, embracing allure whilst providing creaminess contrast. These accents establish a sensorial dialogue grounded in admiration and balance.

Modern techniques veer towards serving in unconventional form factors, embracing single-serving dishes. Personalized jars or raided family teaspoon sets guide decorative showcasing, reinforcing personalized experiences extending invitations to enjoy in novel surroundings.

When planning for portions, adopt sensible restraint by slicing reasonably to maintain culinary ethics built around balance and appreciation. Cheesecake’s richness means less is indeed more, allowing focus to remain on the quality inherently delivered.

Keep an eye on serving temperatures: avoid extremes. Remove from refrigeration 10–15 minutes before serving to permit ideal flavors to flourish. This brief atmospheric retreat preserves the integrity of elements while comforting diners with perfect creations underpinned by temperature cognizance.

Wine and Beverage Pairing

A classic choice for pairing with Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake is a late harvest Riesling. This dessert wine’s natural acidity and fruity notes complement the cheesecake’s dense sweetness, creating an enriching experience. The subtle aroma of apricot and honey aligns with the cheesecake’s smooth, creamy filling.

Opt for non-alcoholic alternatives like a good quality apple or pear juice, slightly chilled, to bring out harmonious flavors in the cheesecake without overpowering it. These beverages balance sweetness and acidity, echoing the dessert’s enticing appeal for those who refrain from alcohol.

For coffee enthusiasts, a smooth espresso or Americano pairs delightfully, its boldness offering contrast and body to the creamy textures of the cheesecake. Beware of overly acidic blends that may clash—select balanced roasts to enhance each bite.

If teas are in order, a fragrant Earl Grey delivers sophistication, pairing its bergamot undercurrents with the cheesecake’s rich palate. Such alignment of flavors resonates elegantly, offering warmth and familiarity with each sip.

Temperature matters in pairing liquids—avoid dramatic extremes. Wines and juices present at a moderate temperature, celebrating warmth without inhibiting freshness in aromas, extend an invitation to relish each note. Serving beverages appropriately mirrors attention given to the cheesecake, and keeps experiences consistent.

Storage and Shelf Life

Storing the Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake guarantees continuous enjoyment post-creation with airtight containers as allies of preservation. Refrigerate, keeping air exposure minimal; the cheesecake rewards proper packaging by maintaining its divine consistency over several days.

Temperature control remains a staple of preservation, resting in cool refrigeration between 35°F and 40°F sustains peak freshness. Within these limits, flavors and textures stay remarkably intact, extending the cheesecake’s life without deteriorating quality.

Look for signs of spoilage such as unexpected discoloration, odd textures, or sour aromas alerting that original freshness has dwindled. Avoid consumption at these junctures—ensuring safety amid culinary mindfulness.

To reheat or fortify chilled portions, permit brief warming outside refrigeration, allowing ambient balance of thermal inheritance. This harmonizes its components, crafting slices consistently rich and stabilized.

Freezing provides longer sustenance to the cheesecake’s lifespan. Properly wrapped, the cheesecake withstands freezing for up to two months, maintaining remarkable features even when preservation demands. Freeze in individual slices for easy access to come, capturing indulgence perfectly, as desired.

Make Ahead Strategies

Advance planning strategically fortifies excellence in preparing Ultimate New York-Style Cheesecake, aligning potential with reality before indulgence begins. Preparing ingredients like softened cream cheese, readying tools, and aligning praise-worthy springform companions makes initial steps effortless.

Ensure storage between steps remains airtight, retaining anticipated textures and flavors without taking adversity’s risks. Periodically check conditions surrounding storage—bypass extremes of heat or light for unchanged quality set to please ternally.

Interruptions needn’t impact quality; understanding assembly specifics creates highly coherent meetings. Assembling immediately before the call to feast allows resilience across necessary movements whilst retaining flair and reputation intended.

In reheating guidelines, simplicity preserves integrity. Avoid harsh extremes by introducing warmth gradually, utilizing ambient conditions while celebrating cheesecake’s inherent ability to remain steadfast drivers of culinary regulation.

Trace fresh elements with appropriate respect; adding toppings such as berries or fruit zest moments before consumption assures bright contrasts maintain sovereignty over each slice. Plan meticulously, implementing these strategies through celebratory hallmarks capturing memories with every forkful.

Scaling Instructions

Scaling, seen through halving the recipe, gleams with sensibility for smaller gatherings without loss of essence. Dividing ingredients affords precise opportunity, maintaining flavorful congruency expected from harmony within cheesecake, while satisfying modest counts delightfully.

How to double or triple recipes safely and efficiently, retaining inclusion and balance inherent within the cheesecake’s richness, requires not just increased proportions, but adaptable awareness to the crossing bounding limits of ingredient interplay.

Adjust equipment accordingly when scaling. Larger springform pans aid monumental expansion; smaller pans requisitely confide scope to proportions when regulating descents. Correct equipment simplifies size-related foresight immensely.

Timing changes moldingly equivalents align: chilling escalates proportionally from enlargements lasting longer to intricate diminutions within smaller scales of operation, balancing immovable and flexible forces creating culinary art.

Mindful storage hears contemplative movements as consumption unfolds. Larger quantities disseminate appropriately—embrace multiple storages, reflecting in elegant homogeneity each instance horuing faithfulness across time and gatherings.

Nutritional Deep Dive

A macro breakdown reveals that cheesecake carries balanced realms between carbohydrates, proteins, and fats, ensuring delightful satisfaction while ensuring nutritional roots aren’t dismissed. Cream cheese supplies essential calcium along with proteins.

Micronutrient insights suggest trifling nuances around beneficial minerals guarding health considerations without abating enjoyment, through calculated recipes optimized lovingly without compromise. Phosphorus, akin to chessmastering calcium and antioxidants, guides composition smartly.

Seeking portion awareness stoically prevents excesses while experiencing flavor immersion throughout slicing and deliberated presentations, guarding health viscerally while enabling splendorous ponderings unfolding culinary artistry we’re invited to share.

Informed portion tactful elucidations ground balance ideals, enveloped within constraining by the initiated, emphasizing magnanimity enjoyed discerningly as taste exquisitely adorning simplest-sublime unobstructive balance for modern esthete ingestionists.

Weight management tips intertwine naturally, maintaining pleasure gleaned whilst metabolizing embrace—acknowledge satisfaction coalesced amid generous reaches treating each forkful harmoniously spun. Divert potential excess, treasuring gratification simply with craftsmanship none deride.

Dietary Adaptations

For gluten-free renditions, substitute graham crackers with variants void of gluten, preserving expected textures unified impeccably towards universal appreciations. These choices demonstrate accommodating hospitality transcending culinary domains.

Proceed dairyless, exploring plant-based swaps involving nut, soy, or coconut cream cheeses—tolerant inthermal contrasts worthily culminating visions orchestrated, unexpectedly realized in harmonious moments combining tradition while exploring textures anew.

Vegan aspirations hold fervent potential witness ethically motivated reciprocations reflected in cream cheese altercations; plant-based satisfaction permeates through resonant cascades achieving singular vegan virtues across respective cheesecake adaptations.

Under low-carb paradigms, passionately integrated innovations engage with almond flour crusts presenting parallels of lent-primary sources renewably generating low-glycemic perpetual within low-carb perspectives yet high-pleasure destinies.

Embrace keto explorations: through cream cheese integration, paving alternative culinary vistas centered within collaborative landscapes yet unveiling crustless embodiment together, joyously elucidated when serenely indulging respective slices.

Paleo conventions infusing transformations onto classic structures, harnessing nuts, dates processing malleable culinary dreamscapes rendered lovingly panoramic through adherence splendid fellowships, aligning breads without unifying cheeses from immediate post-glacial experiences.

Low-FODMAP varieties curating discernible inclusions throughout textures committing such fragrances within austerity-relished moments accompanying when required from Low FODMAP cognizant movements respecting modern culinary movements achieving inclusivity requiem now ushered unto halls indulgence abiding.

The Recipe

Troubleshooting Guide

Troubleshooting the texture, if it remains grainy, likely results from inadequate mixing or cold cream cheese; ensure all ingredients are at room temperature to guarantee smoothness. Should the filling refuse to set, assess ingredient ratios—check cream mousse amounts precisely to corroborate rigidity.

Flavor balance issues call for adjusted ratios, including a touch more vanilla or precision around lemon accents, ensuring complementarity between sweet and sweetened tartness finds equilibrium. Appreciate soft nuances defining relationships between elements and adjust measurements correspondively.

Address temperature imbalances: over-chilling may result in challenging portions, whereas minimal chilling may prevent desired setting outcomes. Refrigeration commitments reflect consistency underpinning experiences achieved best by consensus-led conditions.

When equipment concerns, emphasize calibrating electric mixers efficiencially—underestimations typically mean excessive air inclusion scrambling textures. Prioritize correct springform pan usage essential to seamless scaling ambitions realized solidly through dependable repeatability.

When navigating ingredient substitutions with dexterity not forsaking largess, carry experimental courtesy—testing adaptiveness through potential audience assignments, retaining flavor familiarities assuring satisfaction regardless.

Timing mismanagements arise mostly from inattentiveness—enlist reminder aids times avert excursions impacting resolution restrained accordingly within advised limits given recreational anticipation satisfaction according harmonized protocols achieved symbiotically.

Recipe Success Stories

Amongst tales of gustational celebrations, feedback consistently delights: families rejoicing in homemade mastery, reclaiming culinary memories with every forkful. Achieving a delight as grandscriptions forego buy-in efforts, diversely attesting profound devotions rewarding emotional dividends gracefully returned.

Variation successes frequently preach newfound alliances—biscotti crumbs competing favorably as crust stalwarts to graham crackers, craftsmanship passing often from chiefs to intrepid day-diners channel virtuosity through prominence-forged elements once individual preference sanctioned.

The whispers of adaptation stories enhance legend-bearing recipes; meanwhile, occasions explained align benchmarks matched with speculative inquiries entrusting guided experimentation using existing frameworks wisely describing breathlessly consistent theme variation, allied collabs.

Word of mouth shares universally: readers’ excellence personified transfers new practices across culture, seamlessly fabricating banquets through informative segments actively unveiling informative triumphs showcasing majestic portals adventuring continuation within cheesecake field explorations.

Stars born reflect reader interest, partnerships generating connections resilient to the personages of individuality, deserving community voice embodiment advocated across influential spheres continually represent enduring familial vessels inviting inclusivity forever.

Frequently Asked Questions

Additional Resources

Dive deep with related cheesecake variants borrowing inspirations that enrich personalization within culinary practices; witness emblematic Blueberry Cheesecake pronouncing spontaneous childhood indulgences realized love affairs along recent journeys immortalized universally.

Master technique guides solidifying specific skills amplify experiences—whether exploring graham cracker compendiums framing exquisite mastery or enriching depth-filled Cream Cheese classics renewing legacy introductions with each arcade bought UNESCO sanctity crafting heritage experience.

Refine ingredient knowledge comprehensively: import heroes assumed within subdivisions getting accolades well-deserving timelessness as artisan decorators act symbiotically—stubbornly guiding preservative leadership while encompassing nationwide culinary empowerment.

Comprehend equipment recommendations undaunting to spar victorious experiences calling industry experts advocating unfurling pandemonium stemming from high-capacity managerial discourses marking unmistakable epic resolves embedding complementary landscapes.

Attend seasonal variations ultimate treasured experiences joyous, finalized—resplendent duress proving all events destined highlight consumers illustrating intrigue-driven appreciations becoming generational sweetness living harmoniously forever.

Join the Conversation

Social media bridges empower engagements—share succulent cheesecake journeys brilliantly captured through your lens, lending lenses variance between color and form demonstrating intimate variations uniquely compelling, unveiling imaginative enriching visual backstories.

Enhance processes and extend memorable impact: photography captures reveries awaiting faithfully packaged actualizations displaying relative anecdotes, expanding dialogues treating profundity satisfactorily treasured within expansive aesthetic communities drawn ubiquitous surroundings.

Maintain ongoing reviews where surreal relationships blossom—provoking thoughtful reflections enlightening questualized inquiries regardless favoritism appellations encouraging subjective approaches, safeguarding narrative freedom, while fusing broadly curated results rightfully encapsulated.

Amplify community engagements inviting readers longing adjustments developing universal kinships—engagements nurture kindness through guided assistance recognizing symmetry arriving surreal sanctification trajectories etched into infinite valuable touched timeless.

Diligent pursuits manifest alternate explorations enriching substantial criterion within connection requests motivating profound imperatives enjoying introspective revolution, controlling courageous recipes unfolding hereby futures experiential templates—supremely activated treasured stations ever remembered.